Former State's Attorney With Over 38 Years of Experience

Building a Strong Dog Bite Case: What You Need to Know

If you’ve been on the receiving end of a dog bite, you may be wondering how to go about constructing a strong case against the animal’s owner. Could you collect damages? Would the courts side with you? What do you need to know and understand to build such a case? Take heart: This blog post will do its best to guide you through the process of constructing a strong case for a dog bite so that you can find the justice you deserve. Along the way, we will shed some light on legal terms, explain the pivotal documents in such cases, and discuss the roles of witnesses in building your dog bite case from the ground up. Read on for more insight into making the strongest case that you can against a negligent pet owner.

Identifying Parties Involved in the Dog Bite Accident

When it comes to building a successful dog bite case, it is imperative that all parties involved in the accident be identified first. This may include the owner of the dog, the victim of the attack, and any witnesses to the incident. Establishing that the person who was attacked was doing nothing to provoke or further agitate the animal is essential in many states where there might be a “dog bite” law in place, which places some responsibility on the person who was bitten. In this case, gathering evidence that supports that assertion as quickly as possible can be critical to success.

On the other hand, there might also be states or provisions within a state’s laws on dogs that provide limited recourse for an owner whose pet has attacked someone if provocation occurs. For instance, if a person entered a yard and approached a dog in a manner considered aggressive, this could reduce or even negate potential financial and legal awards against an owner whose pet causes harm from an attack. It is important for attorneys to understand which dog bite laws are relevant to their clients’ cases in order to ensure justice is served and liability is accurately placed.

In either instance, both sides should approach identifying those involved with care and caution. Keep records of all documents pertaining to information useful in coming to conclusions about who is legally liable. Taking statements from witnesses and medical professionals who have treated victims at any point can influence outcomes positively or adversely for each side in regards to any potential settlement amounts discussed by attorneys handling these matters.

Ultimately, having an accurate representation of how events unfolded prior to a dog bite incident makes all the difference when handling a case such as this. With this in mind, accumulating data on not only the owners of dogs potentially involved but also victims of an attack becomes a necessary step for understanding what happened before legal action can proceed forward.

Obtaining Data on the Dog’s Owners and Victims

Obtaining data on the dog’s owners and victims is often a crucial step in bringing a successful dog bite case. It’s important to draw out different perspectives on the incident, including when and where it took place and who was involved in it. As such, relevant information should be gathered from both parties: the owner of the dog and the victim of the bite.

Gathering evidence from the dog owner can include asking them to provide basic information about themselves, such as their name and address. This could also include their insurance details, if they have any type of coverage that covers dog bites. Additionally, obtaining medical records of past veterinarian visits with the dog can also be beneficial. This includes recent rabies vaccinations or any other evidence affirming that the animal was properly cared for before and after the incident in question.

It’s also important to get information on what provoked the bite and any relevant circumstances surrounding it at that specific moment. Interviewing witnesses can also be quite valuable in gaining an accurate perspective on what occurred prior to the incident. Furthermore, questioning the victim of the incident is paramount for further verification purposes, including gathering contact details if possible. This helps ensure that both sides are heard justly during proceedings, which ultimately increases one’s chances for success when building a strong case.

Ultimately, it is crucial to acquire as much pertinent information as possible from all parties involved in order to create a more comprehensive picture of exactly what happened leading up to the incident at hand. This data-driven approach will greatly help one secure better results when building a strong dog bite case. With this key piece of information thoughtfully collected, it is now time to move on to considering how to gather evidence of liability tied to this incident, which will be discussed further in the next section.

Gathering Evidence of Liability

When it comes to building a strong dog bite case, gathering evidence of liability is an essential part of the process. When attempting to answer the question of liability, some key areas to consider include whether or not the responsible parties knew about their dog’s potential for aggression and if they used reasonable measures to keep the public safe. It is also important to understand the legal status of the victim in relation to the animal in order to determine who is legally responsible.

On one hand, some believe that pet owners should be held legally responsible for any damages incurred by their animals, regardless of whether or not they had any knowledge that their animal may become violent or display aggressive behaviors. On the other hand, there are some who believe that as long as the pet owner is found to lack negligence in their care-giving duties and shows no knowledge that their animal would have caused injury to another person, then they should not have to take responsibility for those damages.

No matter which side you take on this debate, it is important that plenty of evidence is gathered and presented in order to build a strong dog bite case. This can be done by collecting veterinary records and police reports, conducting interviews with witnesses, and even obtaining letters from trainers or veterinarians indicating prior knowledge of aggressive behavior from the animal in question. Collecting all relevant documents and statements from both sides can help paint a more accurate picture of what happened leading up to the incident and provide better insight into assigning liability in these types of cases.

Making sure you cover all your bases when it comes to gathering evidence of liability can be a crucial factor in determining who is ultimately responsible and bringing justice for victims involved in dog-related injuries. By utilizing professional help from animal behavior experts, attorneys, or law enforcement officials, you can help ensure that all facts pertaining to this issue have been considered before making a decision on who is at fault. With this information now in mind, it’s time to consider collecting witness testimonies from individuals who were present during the incident; this critical step can make or break building a successful case.

Collecting Witness Testimonies

Witness testimony can be a powerful tool in the arsenal of evidence when it comes to building a strong dog bite case. Witness testimony is a form of indirect evidence, that, unlike physical or scientific evidence, relies on people’s accounts of what occurred. Usually, this involves statements given by individuals present at the time of the incident and can form an important detail to establish liability.

When attempting to get witness testimony for your case, it is best to consider both sides of the argument. For example, if someone witnessed the dog bite occur, they would commonly be called upon to testify as to the nature of the incident. On the other hand, if someone can also argue that the event was caused not by any fault of the owner but rather by something entirely else, such as a child running away from the dog and provoking them, It is important to have witnesses testify about how exactly this event happened, as it plays an important role in establishing liability or negating it completely.

In cases where no one is present at the time of the incident, the local authority could provide useful information such as prior registration and socialization documentation about the animal, which may help give a clear picture of what transpired leading up to the incident. Additionally, some questions about prior behavior or known circumstances regarding the owner can be addressed with these documents.

Collecting relevant witness testimonies can go a long way in helping build your case; however, there are other legal techniques and strategies that are just as important when constructing your case. Applying such techniques effectively requires insight into the laws governing pet ownership, which will be discussed in more detail in the following section.

Applying Legal Techniques to Build the Case

With witness testimonies established, the next steps involve applying legal techniques to build the case. This is a critical component of successfully presenting your dog bite case and demonstrating that justice has been served. On one hand, it’s important to demonstrate that you gave reasonable care and attention to an animal that was on the property of another. Establishing a duty of care in this context can help support your case from a legal standpoint. Additionally, it’s important to examine whether or not a precedent has been set, either through previous cases or laws pertaining to dog bites in the jurisdiction you are filing suit within.

On the other hand, it’s equally important to evaluate any extenuating circumstances beyond what can be reasonably expected from a person when it comes to being responsible for a particular animal. Did the person own the dog? Did they know of any breed-specific traits that could heighten the risk of injury? These are all considerations for how best to approach legal techniques for building your case. Being able to establish cause and effect between prior knowledge of behavior and failure to take action is key to winning any sort of legal action related to dog bites.

With this now established, the importance of evaluating potential behavior issues with an experienced professional is paramount. Consulting experts in animal behavior serves as an avenue for better understanding the potential risks associated with different breeds and situations. This helps pave the way for building the strongest possible case when attempting to seek justice due to a dog bite injury or damages resulting from such an incident.

Consulting Experts in Animal Behavior

When it comes to strengthening a case involving animal bites, consulting experts in animal behavior can provide a critical boost. This type of expert witness is particularly helpful for cases that hinge on an animal’s past behavior and any prior training or abuse the dog may have experienced. By carefully analyzing the circumstances surrounding the attack, a forensic psychologist or veterinarian can offer insight into how and why the animal acted as it did.

Though this professional testimony is invaluable in many cases, there are arguments both for and against it, depending on the context of each situation. On one side, testifying experts may be able to explain why an animal behaved as it did and offer ideas on how best to prevent another such incident from occurring in the future. Furthermore, an expert’s testimony can make key evidence more persuasive by providing impartial analysis about whether or not certain details of the incident point to negligence or malice and whether any available training or safety measures should have been deployed in the specific circumstances.

On the other hand, there are some potential downsides that must also be considered. For example, opponents might argue that their opinions are overly subjective and prone to misinterpretation, making it hard to reach an unbiased verdict. Additionally, there may be discrepancies between reported facts and what truly occurred during the incident; poorly framed questions from opposing counsel could lead to skewed results during cross-examination. While there may be times when consulting an expert is beneficial, attorneys must always weigh their options thoroughly before opting in favor of potentially expensive testimony that could make or break a court decision.

Though its ultimate value will depend on each particular situation, nothing should be decided until all elements are taken into consideration, including expert consultation when deemed necessary. No matter what approach one takes with their case, attorneys need to know they can rely on accurate information to build a strong legal defense. From there, they must turn their attention towards taking their case before a judge, a step that will require further review and careful deliberation before reaching a resolution.

Taking the Case to Court

The decision to take a dog bite case to court can be difficult. It requires a thorough understanding of the legal process, the ability to effectively present evidence to a jury, and a careful calculation of potential risks and rewards. While it is possible to represent the victim of a dog bite yourself or with the help of legal counsel, consultation with experts in animal behavior may be beneficial to successfully achieving a favorable outcome.

When taking the case to court, it is important for both sides to adequately prepare for trial. This includes a thorough investigation of the facts surrounding the incident, developing a strong argument that supports their position, assembling proper witnesses and evidence, and practicing effective courtroom presentation techniques. Witnesses such as veterinarians, animal behaviorists, eyewitnesses who saw the event occur, and other experts may be engaged depending on the situation.

The victim’s attorney must establish that the defendant was legally liable for causing the injury through either negligence or an intentional act. Furthermore, they must also demonstrate that the dog was not provoked by the actions of the victim prior to being attacked. Therefore, it is important for both sides to present any speeches, physical evidence, or scientific studies to support their arguments.

The defendant’s attorney will often try to show that any damages awarded should be reduced if certain mitigating factors existed prior to the attack, such as violations of local laws or ordinances regarding the containment of animals or past incidents involving the same animal and owner. It is also common that strict liability statutes are invoked in order to shift responsibility for an animal’s injuries or harm away from their owner. In these cases, attorneys must prove that all required elements have been met in order for the strict liability doctrine to apply.

Finally, it is critical that all parties involved agree on an appropriate amount of damages award if they intend for litigation in court proceedings to end without a jury trial. When setting damages awards objectively and accurately, attorneys should consider factors such as medical expenses associated with treatment due to bite or attack-related injuries; emotional trauma resulting from experience; pain and suffering; loss of enjoyment of life; diminishment of earning capacity; mental anguish; punitive damages; and property damage caused by an animal, if applicable, such as destruction of clothing or other personal items.

It is important for both sides to share any relevant information they have about the incident while respecting the rights of individuals involved throughout the duration of proceedings. Gathering all necessary information during pre-trial and determining appropriate remedies before going into court can help reduce potential costs associated with litigation, in addition to reducing the amount of time invested by victims as well as defendants seeking resolution through the formal court process.


Building a strong case after a dog bite is crucial. Contact us today to ensure your rights are protected.

Building a strong case after a dog bite is crucial to protecting your rights and seeking the compensation you deserve. At Michael J. Brennan, our experienced legal team is here to guide you through every step of the process. With our knowledge and expertise in dog bite cases, we will work tirelessly to build a solid foundation for your claim.

 Our compassionate attorneys understand the physical and emotional impact that dog bite incidents can have on victims. By contacting us at (708) 290-7072, you can rest assured that your case will be handled with care and dedication. We will listen to your story, gather evidence, and fight for your rights in pursuit of justice.

Don’t face the legal complexities alone; let Michael J. Brennan help you build a strong case and achieve the compensation you deserve.



Get a Free Case Evaluation

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.