Former State's Attorney With Over 38 Years of Experience

person talking on a cell phone while looking at a damaged vehicle headlight

What to expect during a criminal investigation

If you ever find yourself swept up in the whirlwind of a criminal investigation, it’s completely normal to feel disoriented and overwhelmed. Uncertainty breeds anxiety, especially when what hangs in the balance could be your good name or even your freedom. That’s why it’s crucial to understand the process ahead. This essential how-to guide will unveil the labyrinth of a criminal investigation, taking apart its complex layers and illuminating each phase—arrest, interrogation, arraignment, and trial—with clarity. Let us arm you with knowledge so you can transform from being simply a ‘subject’ into an informed participant in your own defense. Don’t let the fear of the unknown dictate your fate; instead, let’s navigate these challenging waters together.

Navigating the Pre-Arrest Investigation

The pre-arrest investigation stage is a crucial phase in the criminal justice process, where law enforcement agencies gather evidence and information to determine whether there is enough probable cause to make an arrest. Understanding how to navigate this stage can be instrumental in safeguarding your rights and ensuring a fair outcome.

During the pre-arrest investigation, law enforcement patrols connect with victims, witnesses, and other relevant individuals to collect statements, gather physical evidence, and question potential witnesses. This process helps build a comprehensive understanding of the facts surrounding the alleged crime. For example, if you were the victim of a robbery, an officer may interview you to gather details about the incident, such as descriptions of the perpetrator, any potential surveillance footage, or witnesses.

It’s vital to remember that cooperation during this stage can significantly impact the outcome of the investigation and any potential legal proceedings. By providing accurate and detailed information about what you witnessed or experienced, you are helping law enforcement build a stronger case against the perpetrator. This not only increases the likelihood of finding justice but also ensures that innocent parties are not wrongly accused or prosecuted.

Importance of Victim Cooperation

Cooperating with law enforcement authorities as a victim of a crime is essential for several reasons. First and foremost, it allows officers to gather valuable evidence that can strengthen the case against the alleged perpetrator. Providing accurate and comprehensive information about what occurred helps paint a detailed picture for investigators, aiding them in securing necessary evidence such as surveillance footage or witness testimonies.

Moreover, your cooperation demonstrates your commitment to seeking justice and holding accountable those who have harmed you or others. By actively participating in the investigation process, you contribute to maintaining public safety and potentially preventing further crimes from occurring. Your willingness to cooperate sends a clear message that criminal behavior will not be tolerated.

In some cases, victims may experience hesitation or fear when it comes to cooperating with law enforcement. This is understandable, as navigating the criminal justice system can feel overwhelming. However, it’s important to remember that support systems exist to assist victims throughout this process. Participating in victim advocacy programs or seeking professional guidance from an attorney or victim advocate can help address any concerns and ensure you are well-informed about your rights during the investigation.

For instance, imagine you were a victim of identity theft and had concerns about providing personal information to law enforcement. By engaging with a victim advocate, you can receive guidance on how to protect yourself and your privacy while collaborating with authorities to bring the perpetrator to justice.

Ultimately, your cooperation plays a significant role in the pursuit of justice. It enables investigators to piece together the necessary evidence, reveals patterns of criminal behavior, and ensures a fair legal process for all parties involved.

Your Rights and Expectations During Police Questioning

Being subjected to a criminal investigation can be an overwhelming and anxiety-inducing experience. One of the key aspects of this process is police questioning, where investigators seek information related to the alleged crime. It is crucial to understand your rights during this phase to protect yourself and ensure a fair process.

During police questioning, you have the right to remain silent, known as the Miranda rights. This means you can choose not to answer any questions that may incriminate you or provide evidence against your interests. It is wise to exercise this right and consult with an attorney before divulging any information.

Additionally, you have the right to request that an attorney be present during questioning. If you do not have the means to hire one, the court may appoint a public defender for you. Having legal counsel by your side can help safeguard your rights, guide you through the process, and offer advice on how best to respond to questions.

It is important to stay calm and composed during police questioning. You should provide truthful answers to any questions that do not incriminate you while remaining mindful of potential pitfalls that could be used against you later in court. Cooperate with law enforcement within reasonable limits without self-incriminating or providing unnecessary information.

The police are responsible for gathering evidence, which includes taking statements from witnesses or individuals involved in the case. The primary purpose of questioning is to obtain relevant information about the alleged crime. However, it is essential to remember that law enforcement officers have their own objectives when conducting interviews. While they may seek clarity and truthfulness, their main goal is often to build a case against a suspect.

Now that we have discussed your rights and expectations during police questioning, let’s turn our attention to the valuable support provided by victim advocates.

Assistance from a Victim Advocate

Dealing with the aftermath of a crime can be overwhelming, emotionally draining, and perplexing. This is where victim advocates play a crucial role in supporting individuals who have been affected by crime. Victim advocates are professionals trained to provide guidance, assistance, and emotional support to help victims navigate the criminal justice system.

Victim advocates can guide you through every step of the legal process, ensuring that your rights as a victim are protected and providing information about your options and the resources available to you. They can explain the investigation process, court proceedings, and potential outcomes to help you make informed decisions concerning your case.

These dedicated professionals can assist in numerous ways, such as by accompanying you during meetings with law enforcement or prosecutors, helping you prepare victim impact statements, and connecting you with necessary resources like counseling services or financial support.

For example, if you are uncertain about whether to report a crime due to fears or concerns about the legal process, a victim advocate can help clarify your options and address any concerns. They are there to listen to your perspective, validate your experiences, and empower you with knowledge.

Victim advocates can also act as intermediaries between victims and law enforcement agencies or the court system. They ensure that victims’ voices are heard and their rights are respected throughout the process. Having someone knowledgeable by your side who understands the complexities of the criminal justice system can provide immense comfort and reassurance during what can be an overwhelming ordeal.

What Follows an Arrest: Arraignment and Pleas

After an arrest is made, the legal process continues with the arraignment, which is a crucial step in the criminal justice system. During the arraignment, the accused appears before a judge or magistrate, who informs them of the formal charges brought against them by the prosecution. This is also the stage where the defendant enters their plea, which could be guilty, not guilty, or no contest.

Imagine a scenario where John has been arrested and charged with burglary. At his arraignment, a judge would inform him that he was officially charged with breaking and entering into a building with the intent to commit a crime. John would then have to enter his plea based on whether he believes he is guilty or innocent of the charges.

It’s important to note that during this stage, it may be in the defendant’s best interest to consult with legal counsel, who can help evaluate the case and provide guidance on what plea to enter. The plea entered at arraignment impacts subsequent proceedings and can determine whether negotiations for a plea bargain will take place or if the case proceeds to trial.

After entering a plea, different scenarios can unfold:

  1. If the defendant pleads guilty: They accept responsibility for the charges against them. In this case, there may be further discussions about sentence recommendations or any potential plea agreement.
  2. If the defendant pleads not guilty: They assert their innocence and dispute the charges brought against them. The case then moves forward towards pretrial procedures such as discovery and motion practice.
  3. If the defendant pleads no contest: They neither admit nor deny guilt but do not contest facing the consequences as if they were found guilty. This type of plea can occur when defendants want to avoid admitting liability in civil proceedings arising from criminal acts.

Each plea comes with its own set of implications and potential consequences that should be carefully considered with the advice of legal counsel. Keep in mind that the plea entered at arraignment is not necessarily final and can be changed later in the process if circumstances or strategies evolve.

Facing an Investigation? Contact Us for Expert Guidance!


If you find yourself facing a criminal investigation, you don’t have to navigate it alone. Our team of experienced attorneys is here to provide you with expert guidance and support during this challenging time. We understand the complexities of criminal investigations and are committed to offering personalized assistance tailored to your unique situation. 

Whether you have questions, need advice, or require representation, don’t hesitate to reach out. Take the first step towards safeguarding your future and protecting your interests by contacting Michael J. Brennan. Let us be your trusted ally throughout the entire investigation process. 

Call us today and get the peace of mind you deserve.

Get a Free Case Evaluation

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.